In the following is my essay written for my first-year English course at Cerritos College. I received an A for this paper.
Legalizing Marijuana: America Would Become a Victim
Should marijuana be legalized? Today, marijuana is an illegal drug in the United States. However, for years Americans have vigorously debated over the issue of the drug-control policy that includes marijuana legalization, no doubt because legalizing this drug could bring both benefits and harms to the public and government. Legalization advocates always bring the potential benefits like economic gain and medical use into debate. On the other hand, opponents strongly argue that legalizing marijuana would be disastrous. Because it is harmful to health and because this drug causes various social problems, marijuana should not be legal.
Smoking marijuana can cause significant health problems. Studies reveal that smokable marijuana is a very dangerous substance that can cause or contribute to both mental and physical health disorders. One great concern is marijuana’s effect on mental health. Marijuana destroys the user’s intelligence and memory function, as John Murray, a professor at St. John’s University, demonstrates, “Marijuana impairs human intellectual judgment and short-term memory as well as human psychomotor function, particularly driving an automobile” (41). Also, this drug can cause psychological disorders that lead users to maladaptive behaviors, such as changes in thought, auditory sensation, and emotions. Mitch Earlywine, Associate Professor of Psychology at the State University of New York at Albany, also points that, “Cannabinoid intoxication can also mimic certain aspects of psychoses like schizophrenia. These psychotic disorders typically include odd thoughts, auditory hallucinations, and inappropriate emotions” (145). Sara McClintock indicates that, “The most serious risk that a typical user ever runs is anxiety, which can be triggered by stress or fatigue—or higher-potency marijuana” (1). Marijuana negatively affects the user’s mental ability to think logically while doing complex work. Jim Parker’s “Marijuana: Health Effects” notifies that, “Pot also reduces logical thinking and calculation skills, and can impair a user’s ability to perform complex tasks” (1). Clearly, marijuana is very dangerous to mental health. The serious problem of marijuana users is the terrible changes in their mood and ability to think. It can impact the user’s ability to perceive, transform, and remember information.
In addition to mental disorders, marijuana has destructive effects on physical health. The two significant physical disorders caused by marijuana use are cardiovascular deterioration and respiratory problems. Parker states that:
Even though increased heart rate only lasts minutes and isn’t a threat to most people, it could add strain for users with heart disorders or high blood pressure […]. A bigger threat to more users is irritation to the lungs and respiratory airways, since users tend to inhale pot deeply and hold it in the lungs for as long as possible. (1)
Since marijuana affects the immune system, Andrea Faiad, in “Dangerous Drug”, claims that, “Marijuana might make it easier to get sick. Marijuana can limit how well the body fights off infections” (28).
Moreover, smoking marijuana may cause cancer. Earleywine informs that, “These data…suggest that cannabis smoke is capable of damaging the bronchial system in ways that may lead to tumors” (157). Indeed, scientists strongly suggest that marijuana contains cancer-causing agents. Parker maintains that, “Even though a direct link with lung cancer is unproven, pot smoke does contain cancer-causing chemicals” (4). One concern is that lung cancer can be caused by marijuana use. Interestingly, the National Institute of Drug Abuse illustrates that, “Marijuana abuse also has the potential to promote cancer of the lungs and other parts of the respiratory tract because it contains irritants and carcinogens” (3). Obviously, this drug affects the physical health negatively. It can make the user’s heart jump more rapidly than usual, and that may cause the high blood pressure. Also, it can irritate the user’s lungs and has the potential effect of causing tumors, including lung cancer.
Marijuana advocates always bring the medical use as their primary justification for marijuana legalization, yet this justification has always been unproven. Lester Grinspoon and James Bakalar, in Marihuana, the Forbidden Medicine, contend that, “In the twentieth century cannabis has been proposed or shown to be useful as a medicine for many disorders and symptoms” (23), but when scientists take a close look at the medical literature and policy, marijuana is not proved to be a medicine, and even medical marijuana may have negative effects. There is no verifiable evidence to justify marijuana to be a legal medicine. Andrea Bardwell, a physician for more than twenty years, argues that:
There is no scientific evidence that qualifies smoked marijuana to be called medicine. Further, there is no support in the medical literature that marijuana, or indeed any medicine, should be smoked as the preferred form of administration. The harms to health are simply too great” (2).
Actually, marijuana has not been proven to be a medicine, and smoking marijuana is not considered a method of treatment.
Even though marijuana may contribute positively to the medical use, it is inefficient and harms the cardiovascular system. In his book The Science of Marijuana, Iversen admits that, “There are clearly several possible therapeutic indications for cannabis based medicines, but for most of them evidence for the clinical effectiveness of the drug is woefully inadequate by modern standards” (174). Iversen clearly indicates that medical marijuana is not a standard treatment, so this drug should be not called medicine. Marijuana is harmful to the heart and should be excluded for treatment. Dr. Iversen adds that:
There are quite profound effects of cannabis on the heart and vascular system. In inexperienced users the drug can cause a large increase in heart rate (up to a doubling) and this could be harmful to someone with a previous history of coronary artery disease or heart failure. Such patients should be excluded from any clinical trails of cannabis-based medicines for this reason. (182)
Marijuana should not be legal for medical treatment because medical marijuana is not only ineffective, it is also unsafe.
In addition, medical marijuana brings certain concerns to scientists. Parker writes, “Perhaps the biggest worry concerns potential effects on the body’s immune system […].Other potential problems center on damage to the lungs and respiratory system […]. Other problems involve the drug’s side effects, particularly speeded-up heart rate” (1). Definitely, Parker explains that there are several negative consequences of medical marijuana on patients, such as immune system destruction, respiratory problems, and heart complication. As medical marijuana may cause many side effects to the patients, this drug should not become legal for medical reasons. Parker makes it clear that medical marijuana can harm the patient’s health. For this reason, marijuana should remain illegal.
Marijuana has been declared officially to be dangerous to health and of no medical value. As claimed by the United State Court of Appeals, marijuana remains a schedule I controlled substance because it is unsafe and has high potential for abuse. The U.S. Department of Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) informs that, “The United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit issued a ruling on May 24, 2002, upholding DEA’s determination that marijuana must remain a schedule I controlled substance” (1). Marijuana must remain a schedule I controlled substance because DEA found marijuana dangerous. The U.S. DEA reveals that:
DEA agreed with the HHS’s conclusions and denied the petition to reschedule marijuana saying that the evidence overwhelmingly leads to the conclusion that marijuana has a high potential for abuse. DEA’s denial of the petition, along with the complete details of the medical and scientific findings made by DEA and the HHS were published.” (1).
Undoubtedly, marijuana would have little chance to be legal since the DEA found many dangers in marijuana officially declared to remain a schedule I controlled substance.
Legalization proponents may argue that legalizing marijuana would cut the cost on drug wars and add the tax revenues to the government. Those legalization proponents may be right, but their arguments are totally misleading because they may overlook the disastrous economic effects of marijuana on American society. Regarding both mental and physical health problems, if marijuana was legalized, the relevant social complication could occur. The public health could actually deteriorate if marijuana became a legal drug, and this deterioration in public health could strongly burden the labor force. One effect of marijuana is that less productive and less healthy laborers would grow dramatically because of the pervasive distribution and use of marijuana after legalization. The other big consequence of marijuana being legalized would be the increasing rate of unemployment or idle workers because employees are mostly required to have drug screening before entering a job or working in the drug-free workplaces. Kathy Gurchiek, an associate editor for HR News, informs that:
Among employers who do administer drug tests, it’s typically part of the pre-employment testing (83.5 percent), or after hiring when there is reasonable suspicion that there is a problem (73.3 percent)…. Other reasons given for workplace drug a test…was in accordance with a client’s requirement (2).
As a result, marijuana users would be discouraged or fail to be hired.
On the other hand, marijuana is one big cause that increases the rate of automobile accidents in the United States. Studies show that there is an association between marijuana users and the risks of accidents. In scientific research, Stephanie Blows, Rebecca Ivers, Jennie Connor, Shanthi Ameratunga, Mark Woodward, and Robyn Norton found that “habitual users of marijuana have about ten times the risk of car crash injury or death compared to infrequent or non-users, after adjustment for other crash-related variables including an objective measure of blood alcohol level” (607). Most likely, other marijuana nonusers may also be affected by the accidents caused by marijuana users. Because marijuana users and the risks of car crashes are dependent, the rise of this drug would logically augment the number of accidents. The increase in car accidents caused by marijuana users would inevitably heighten the injury and death rate in the United States.
Besides the accidents, this drug also impacts American youth and the education system. The pervasive distribution of marijuana from legalization would probably spread out to American adolescents. Alain Joffe and Yancy Samuel note that “the recent Supreme Court decision and experience with the Synar Amendment suggest that, if marijuana were legalized, restrictions on the sale and advertising of the substance to young people would prove daunting” (636). Youth with mental and physical disorders caused by marijuana would be less likely to have awareness about their school work. As a result, marijuana use among adolescents could rationally burden American education system and lead teens to academic failure. Even worse, the drop-out rate may also go up alarmingly, and American human capital would be less productive.
Additionally, marijuana may contribute to delinquent behavior and gang involvement, which are the risk factors of American teens leading to crime and violence. A national report shows that a teen, who uses marijuana, is often involved in gangs and commits violence. In Teens, Drugs, and Violence, the Office of National Drug Control Policy reports that:
Violent acts by teens are also linked to how frequently a teen smokes marijuana…the instances of physically attacking people, destroying property, and stealing increase in direct proportion to the frequency with which teens smoke marijuana…. Early use of marijuana—the drug most widely used by teens—is a warning sign for later gang involvement. Gang members are more likely to engage in criminal activity and substance abuse than their peers. Other than alcohol, marijuana is the most widely used substance in gang life. Children who use marijuana are nearly four times more likely to join gangs. Being a member of gang dramatically increases a teen’s risk of being a victim of violence, not just a perpetrator (2).
The concern of the Office of National Drug Control Policy is the involvement in gangs among teens because of marijuana use, and when those teens join gangs, they mostly commit violence, felonies, or crimes.
Most American parents have been trying very hard to raise teens to avoid drugs. Ironically, if their children were addicted to marijuana, those parents would feel very disappointed, or it would cause big problems in American families. More severely, when parents see their children facing academic failure in school, joining gangs, or committing violence because of marijuana, those parents would definitely feel miserable. Thus, most parents would dramatically disagree with marijuana legalization. In fact, those parents are not happy with marijuana abuse because many teens are in treatment from marijuana dependence each year. Karen P. Tandy shows, “Marijuana use can lead to dependence and abuse. Marijuana was the second most common illicit drug responsible for drug treatment admissions…more teens are in treatment each year for marijuana dependence” (4).
With the health effects and the social problems, if the government legalized this drug, the negative consequences on health and society would rise rapidly because legalization would lead to dramatic increase in distribution and demand. If it was legalized, the price would drop and the demand would rise. Joffe and Yancy maintain that, “Marijuana is cheap and easy to produce; if it were legalized, its price likely would decrease below current levels” (636). Actually, the drop in price of marijuana would contribute to a significant increase in demand. In fact, marijuana is a plant, so it can be easily planted by households. Iversen informs, “The Cannabis plant is a lush, fast-growing annual, which can reach maturity in 60 days when grown indoors under optimum heat and light conditions” (182). This signals that there would be a greater possibility of marijuana being grown indoors if it were legalized. Since it can be planted at home, marijuana would be more easily and rapidly distributed from one home to the other. Therefore, marijuana distribution and abuse would rise progressively. If marijuana became widespread after legalization, the adverse health, safety, social, academic, economic, and behavioral consequences would accelerate, and that could make social control become even more complicated. The Government most likely would spend a lot of money to minimize these effects caused by marijuana if it were legalized.
Even though it may bring some potential advantages, marijuana is more harmful than beneficial. From mental disorders to physical illness, from academic failure to social chaos, legalizing marijuana would actually cause many negative effects on America. Marijuana, like other drugs, has a variety of relevant dangers, including the increased risk of death due to cancer, heart diseases, respiratory problems, accidents, violence, and crime. Since the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia upheld this drug as a dangerous substance, it has little chance to become legal.
Argumentative essay on Marijuana written by Monirath Siv
Work Cited
Bardwell, Andrea. “A Haze of Misinformation Clouds Issue of
Medical Marijuana.” Los Angeles Time. 22 Jul. 2003: B13. National 5 Newspapers. ProQuest. Cerritos College Lib., Norwalk CA. 1 Nov. 2007. .
Blows, Stephanie, Rebecca Ivers, Jennie Connor, Shangthi
Ameratunga, Mark Woodward, and Robyn Norton. “Marijuana use and car crash injury.” Addiction May 2005: 100. Health Source. Ebscohost. Cerritos College Lib., Norwalk CA. 1 November 2007. .
Earleywine, Mitch. Understanding Marijuana: A New Look at the
Scientific Evidence. New York: Oxford UP, 2002. NetLibrary. Cerritos College Lib., 1 November 2007.
.
Faiad, Andrea. “Dangerous Drug.” Current Health Oct. 2007: 31.
MasterFile Premier. Ebscohost. Cerritos College Lib., Norwalk CA. 1 November 2007. .
Grinspoon, Lester and James Bakalar. Marijuana The Forbidden
Medicine. New Haven: Yale UP, 1997.
Gurchiek, Kathy. “Employer Testing Credited for Lower Drug-Use.”
HRMagaizine Jun. 2007: 36-41. MasterFile Premier.Ebscohost. Cerritos College Lib., Norwalk CA. 1 November 2007. .
Joffe, Alain and Samuel Yancy. “Legalization of Marijuana:
Potential Impact on Youth.”
Pediatrics. Jun. 2004 632-638. MasterFile Premier. Ebscohost. Cerritos College Lib., Norwalk CA. 1 November 2007. .
Iversen, Leslie L. The Science of Marijuana. New York: Oxford
UP, 2000.
McClintock, Sara. “Marijuana: pot and personality memory,
motivation and behavior.” Do It Now Foundation 2002: 8C. Health Source. Ebscohost. Cerritos College Lib., Norwalk, CA. 1 November 2007. .
Murray, John B. “Marijuana's Effects on Human Cognitive
Functions, Psychomotor Functions, and Personality.” Journal of
General Psychology Jan. 1986: 133. MasterFILE Premier. Ebscohost. Cerritos College Lib., Norwalk CA. 1 November 2007. .
Parker, Jim. “Marijuana: Health Effects.” Do It Now Foundation
2002: 8c. Health Source.Ebscohost. Cerritos College Lib., Norwalk CA. 1 November 2007. .
---. “Marijuana: Medical Uses is Pot Medicine?” Do It Now
Foundation 2002: 5c. Health Source. Ebscohost. Cerritos College Lib., Norwalk CA. 1 November 2007. .
United States. Department of Drug Enforcement Administration.
High Court Upholds Marijuana as Dangerous Drug. 6 June 2002. 1 Nov. 2007. .
United States. Department of Drug Enforcement Administration.
Marijuana: The Myths Are Killing Us. By Karen P. Tandy. 26 April 2005. 1 Nov. 2007. .
United States. National Institute on Drug Abuse. NIDA InfoFacts:
Marijuana. April 2006. 1 Nov. 2007.
.
United States. Office of National Drug Control Policy. Teens,
Drugs and Violence. June 2007. 1 Nov. 2007.
Violence.pdf>.